Why Most Clients Fire Their Advisor — and It Isn't Returns

Clients rarely fire their financial advisor because their portfolio underperformed. That is the central finding of a 2023 Morningstar study, which found that the quality of financial advice and services was cited by 32% of departing clients, followed by the quality of the advisor relationship at 21%. Cost came third, and investment returns accounted for only 11% of responses.

The study's findings are echoed by advisors who regularly take on clients from other firms. Interviews conducted for the article with advisors such as Marshall Rathmell of BCR Wealth Strategies, Kathleen Kenealy of Katapult Financial Planning, Jared Weinerman of Impact Financial Planning, and Chelsea Mieczkowski of Better Planning point to the same pattern: clients leave when they feel unheard, uneducated, or unsure what their advisor is doing for them.

Communication is the most common complaint. Clients describe long silences, unanswered calls, or feeling that they were managing the relationship themselves. Morningstar's research suggests that when clients hear nothing from their advisor, they assume nothing is being done, even if the advisor is working behind the scenes.

Another recurring theme is the growing demand for comprehensive planning that connects investments, retirement, taxes, estate planning, insurance, education, and cash flow. Clients also want advice in plain English. The larger point, the advisors argue, is that value is now measured by the confidence a client feels leaving a meeting, not by the sophistication of a strategy.

Advertisement

What Inheriting Advisors Hear: Communication, Planning, and Intimidation

Morningstar's Numbers Point to a Perception Problem

The study's data separates what advisors think clients care about from what actually drives departures. Only 11% of responses cited investment returns, while advice quality and relationship quality together accounted for 53%. The practical implication, drawing on the advisors' reports, is that performance shortfalls may be survivable if the relationship is strong, while silence and inattention can push clients out even when results are acceptable. That link between the percentages and client behavior is interpretation rather than a measured conclusion.

Holistic Planning Becomes the Differentiator

Weinerman's observation that clients often arrive without having experienced true comprehensive planning reflects a broader shift in the profession. Investment management has become a commodity, so advisors increasingly compete on coordination across retirement, tax, estate, insurance, education, and cash flow. The article offers no data on how widely such planning is offered, so this should be read as an industry view rather than a verified fact.

Intimidation and the Education Gap

Mieczkowski's point that clients sit through meetings feeling confused but unwilling to say so highlights a hidden risk for advisors: technical complexity can undermine confidence even when the advice is sound. Translating strategies into plain English and ending meetings with clear next steps is presented as a direct remedy. This is anecdotal, but it is consistent with Morningstar's finding that advisors often fail to communicate their value.

What Advisors Can Do With Morningstar's Findings

For advisors who want to act on the study, the reported drivers suggest concrete changes:

  • Demonstrate the work clients cannot see. Morningstar found clients assume silence means inaction, so establish a proactive contact cadence and summarize what was done between meetings.
  • Lead with planning, not portfolio management. As Impact Financial Planning's Jared Weinerman noted, clients value coordination across retirement, taxes, estate planning, insurance, education, and cash flow.
  • Speak plainly. Chelsea Mieczkowski of Better Planning translates technical strategies into everyday language and closes each meeting with simple next steps — a model for reducing the intimidation that pushes clients away.
  • Set expectations early. Morningstar's three drivers include mismatched expectations established at the start of the relationship; clarify how often clients will hear from you and what your fee covers.