Key Points
- Pomona College's administrators grew from 39 in 1981 to 358 in 2026 — a ninefold increase — while student enrollment rose only 20%, from 1,443 to 1,732.
- The expansion reflects Parkinson's Law dynamics: bureaucracies create work to justify their own growth, with wellness task forces, gratitude gardens, and layered dean positions proliferating.
- The financial trade-off is significant: money spent on administrative salaries and programming could fund faculty hiring or tuition reduction, yet Pomona's listed cost of attendance has reached $95,670.
How Pomona College's Administration Grew Ninefold While Enrollment Barely Moved
A professor at Pomona College has published a detailed analysis showing that the college's administrative staff grew from 39 people in 1981 to 358 in 2026 — a ninefold increase — while student enrollment rose only 20%, from 1,443 to 1,732. The number of tenured and tenure-track faculty grew just 22%, from 148 to 180. The figures, compiled with colleague John E. Seery, paint a stark picture of how one elite liberal arts college's bureaucracy expanded far faster than its core academic mission.
The article traces this growth to what historian C. Northcote Parkinson described in 1955: bureaucracies tend to expand regardless of actual workload, as administrators justify hiring subordinates who in turn need their own staff. At Pomona, the dean of students office now oversees approximately 70 administrators — compared to four in 1981 — with titles including a dean of campus life, separate deans for first-year, sophomore, and junior classes, and directors of everything from student media to accessibility services. The college has also created a Wellness Task Force, a 15-person Staff Council, and contracted with an external group for dialogue workshops.
The financial implications are significant. Pomona's listed cost of attendance for on-campus students is now $95,670, and the college faces what the author describes as a financial squeeze. The administrators' proposed solution — hiring more staff to increase fundraising — strikes the author as self-perpetuating. The article notes that the pattern extends well beyond Pomona: at MIT, faculty grew 9% between 1985 and 2023 while administrators grew 189%. Other universities cited include NC State, the University of Washington, NYU, and Georgetown, all of which have invested heavily in wellness programming and expanded administrative roles.
At a Glance
| Institution | Pomona College Private liberal arts college in Claremont, California, subject of the analysis |
| Key Figure | 39 administrators (1981) → 358 (2026) Ninefold increase over 45 years, excluding clerical and support staff |
| Student Enrollment | 1,443 (1981) → 1,732 (2026) 20% growth, far outpacing faculty and administrator ratios |
| Faculty Count | 148 (1981) → 180 (2026) Tenured and tenure-track only; 22% increase |
| Cost of Attendance | $95,670 Current listed annual cost for on-campus students |
| Key Concept | Parkinson's Law C. Northcote Parkinson's 1955 theorem that work expands to fill available time |
| Comparative Data | MIT: faculty +9%, administrators +189% (1985–2023) Cited study showing the trend extends beyond Pomona |
| Dean of Students Office | ~70 administrators Current staffing under one dean, versus four in 1981 |
Where the Sides Stand
Professor (article author) and critics of administrative growth
Position: Administrative expansion represents wasteful make-work that diverts resources from teaching and drives up tuition costs.
Role in the story: Author of the critique, drawing on 45 years of observation at Pomona and comparative data from other institutions.
Motivation: Concern that higher education's financial model is unsustainable and that students bear costs for unnecessary bureaucracy.
College administrators and wellness/HR program staff
Position: Not explicitly stated in the article, but their activities — wellness programs, staff councils, professional development — suggest a belief that these services support student and employee well-being.
Role in the story: Subject of criticism; their programs and staffing levels are the focus of the professor's analysis.
Motivation: Inferred: institutional priorities around student wellness, community building, and employee development, though the article does not present their direct response. (our reading)
Why Administrative Bloat Persists Despite Financial Pressure
Why Parkinson's Law Thrives in Higher Education
The article's core insight is that administrative growth is not driven by student needs or institutional complexity alone — it follows its own logic. Parkinson's Law predicts that bureaucrats will create work for themselves and for each other, and higher education provides ideal conditions for this dynamic. Unlike a business facing quarterly profit pressure, colleges have multiple revenue streams (tuition, donations, endowments, government support) and diffuse accountability. No single stakeholder bears direct responsibility for administrative headcount, and the benefits of new programs are visible while their costs are spread across tuition and budgets.
The wellness programs, gratitude gardens, and dialogue workshops described in the article serve a dual purpose: they provide genuine services to some community members, but they also justify the existence of the administrators who run them. As the author notes, a student who signed up for several Sustained Dialogue Institute workshops found each one canceled for lack of interest — yet they are offered again this year. The programs persist not because of demand but because their elimination would threaten administrative roles.
The Financial Trade-Off Nobody Wants to Name
Pomona's $95,670 cost of attendance makes the trade-off explicit. Every dollar spent on an associate dean for student development is a dollar not spent on faculty salaries, financial aid, or tuition reduction. The article notes that the college faces a financial squeeze despite this high sticker price — a paradox that suggests the administrative apparatus has become a structural cost driver rather than a response to revenue growth. The proposed solution of hiring more fundraisers to pay for more administrators is circular: it adds cost in the hope of generating revenue, with no guarantee the ratio improves.
For context, this pattern is not unique to Pomona. The MIT data — 9% faculty growth versus 189% administrative growth over 38 years — indicates a sector-wide phenomenon. Higher education has become a service industry where non-academic functions (wellness, career services, diversity programs, compliance) have expanded dramatically, often in response to student expectations, regulatory requirements, and risk management concerns. But the article's critique suggests that at some institutions, the growth has become self-justifying rather than needs-driven.
What This Means for Higher Education's Business Model
The article arrives at a moment when many small colleges face enrollment declines and financial pressure. Pomona is elite and well-endowed, but its experience offers a warning for less wealthy institutions: administrative bloat is easier to grow than to shrink. Once positions and programs exist, they develop constituencies and institutional inertia. The author's comparison to a "midlevel paper company in Pennsylvania" is telling — corporate America has spent decades flattening management layers and outsourcing non-core functions, while higher education has moved in the opposite direction.
The implications extend beyond cost. If administrative growth reflects a shift in institutional priorities away from teaching and toward services and risk management, it may also affect the student experience. The article's tone suggests that faculty see this as a loss of institutional focus. For prospective students and families, the question is whether the services justify the price. For college leaders, the challenge is whether they can articulate a compelling case for the current model — or whether they will face increasing pressure to justify each administrative role.
What This Means for Tuition-Paying Families and Higher Ed Leaders
The most important insight: Pomona's administrative growth is a leading indicator of a sector-wide cost problem that will face increasing scrutiny as tuition reaches six figures.
For tuition-paying families, the article raises a direct question: what are you getting for $95,670 per year? The data suggests that a growing share of that cost funds administrative services rather than instruction. Families evaluating colleges should ask about faculty-to-student ratios, the percentage of the budget spent on instruction versus administration, and whether wellness and support programs are actually utilized. The article's example of canceled workshops that continue to be offered is a red flag worth probing during campus visits.
For higher education leaders, the pressure is building. The MIT data and the Pomona case study provide ammunition for critics who argue that colleges have lost cost discipline. Institutions that can demonstrate efficient administration — and articulate why each role exists — will be better positioned as scrutiny intensifies. The next 12–24 months will likely bring more attention to administrative headcount from trustees, donors, and policymakers.
Metrics worth watching: Pomona's next published budget and staffing figures; whether peer institutions announce administrative hiring freezes or restructuring; and whether the U.S. Department of Education or accreditation bodies introduce new reporting requirements on administrative costs.
Risk & Opportunity Assessment
| Commercial Risk | Medium | Pomona faces a financial squeeze despite $95,670 cost of attendance; administrative costs limit flexibility for financial aid or tuition reduction. |
| Competitive Risk | Low | Pomona's elite status insulates it from short-term enrollment competition, but cost pressures could affect positioning versus peer institutions. |
| Regulatory Risk | Low | No specific regulatory threat is cited, though growing scrutiny of higher education costs could lead to policy attention. |
| Reputation Risk | Medium | The article, published in The Chronicle of Higher Education, could amplify criticism of Pomona's spending priorities and administrative culture. |
| Technology Disruption | Low | The article does not address technology; the focus is on human administrative roles and programs. |
| Commercial Opportunity | Low | The article frames administrative growth as a cost problem, not an opportunity; no new revenue streams are identified. |
Comments 0